The main difference between mast-o khiar and tzatziki is their seasoning and consistency: mast-o khiar combines yoghurt and cucumber with mint, while tzatziki typically includes garlic, olive oil and lemon juice or vinegar in a thicker yoghurt base. Recipes vary, but mast-o khiar generally tastes milder. You'll often eat it as a side dish, while you'll commonly find tzatziki served as a dip or sauce.
What ingredients are in mast-o khiar and tzatziki?
Mast-o khiar is a Persian yoghurt and cucumber dish; its name means yoghurt and cucumber. To make a basic version, you need plain yoghurt, cucumber, dried mint and salt. You can also add black pepper or, for a more elaborate version, chopped walnuts, raisins or dried edible rose petals.
Tzatziki is a Greek yoghurt and cucumber dip or sauce. You typically make it with strained yoghurt, grated cucumber, crushed garlic, olive oil, salt and either lemon juice or vinegar. Dill is common, although you can use mint or leave out the herbs.
Garlic is the clearest distinction in many everyday versions, but it isn't an absolute rule. Some mast-o khiar recipes include garlic, and the amount in tzatziki ranges from subtle to assertive. Check a recipe's ingredients rather than expecting every version to follow the same formula.
- Shared base: plain yoghurt, cucumber and salt.
- Typical mast-o khiar seasoning: dried mint, sometimes with pepper.
- Optional mast-o khiar additions: walnuts, raisins and dried edible rose petals.
- Typical tzatziki seasoning: garlic, olive oil, lemon juice or vinegar, often with dill.
How do mast-o khiar and tzatziki taste and feel?
In mast-o khiar, you'll usually taste the yoghurt, fresh cucumber and mint most clearly. Most of its acidity comes from the yoghurt itself, so you don't normally need to add lemon juice. Walnuts bring a slight crunch, raisins add sweetness, and a small amount of rose petals adds a floral aroma.
Tzatziki usually tastes more garlicky, with extra acidity from lemon juice or vinegar. Olive oil adds richness, while dill gives it a different herbal flavour from mast-o khiar made with mint. You don't need chilli or hot spices for either dish.
The texture depends largely on yoghurt thickness and cucumber moisture. Mast-o khiar often has a softer, spoonable consistency with small pieces of cucumber. Tzatziki generally holds its shape better because you make it with strained yoghurt and grated cucumber with much of its liquid squeezed out.
You can vary the consistency of either dish. Use strained yoghurt for thick mast-o khiar; thin yoghurt or poorly drained cucumber can make your tzatziki runny. Neither dish is a yoghurt drink.
How do you keep mast-o khiar and tzatziki from getting watery?
Use plain, unsweetened yoghurt for either dish. Full-fat yoghurt gives you a richer result, but lower-fat yoghurt can work if it's thick enough. If your yoghurt looks thin, strain it in a cloth-lined sieve in the fridge before adding the other ingredients.
For mast-o khiar, finely dice crisp cucumber or grate it if you prefer a more uniform texture. You usually don't need to peel thin-skinned cucumbers, but peel tougher skins and remove any large, watery seed core. Mix the cucumber with yoghurt, crushed dried mint and salt, then taste before adding any optional ingredients.
For tzatziki, squeeze the grated cucumber in a clean kitchen cloth or press it firmly in a sieve. Stir it into thick yoghurt with finely crushed garlic, olive oil and a little lemon juice or vinegar. Add salt and herbs, then taste again after a short rest in the fridge, as the raw garlic flavour can become stronger.
- Drain the cucumber first rather than trying to thicken a watery mixture later.
- Add salt, garlic and acid gradually so you can control the balance.
- Use garnishes sparingly, especially dried mint and rose petals.
- Chill the finished dish and stir it before serving.
What should you serve with mast-o khiar and tzatziki?
Serve mast-o khiar in a small bowl alongside Persian rice dishes, kebabs or other grilled meats. You can take a spoonful between bites or eat it with bread. Its mild seasoning makes it a good accompaniment to dishes that already contain plenty of herbs, spices or acidity.
Serve tzatziki with grilled meat, vegetable fritters, bread or raw vegetables. You can also spread it inside wraps or sandwiches: its thicker consistency helps keep it from soaking into the bread as a thinner yoghurt mixture might.
Either can be a dip, provided you make it thick enough. If you're serving mast-o khiar with bread for scooping, use strained yoghurt and drain the cucumber well. For a spoonable side dish, ordinary yoghurt and finely diced cucumber may give you the consistency you prefer.
Can you substitute mast-o khiar for tzatziki?
You can usually substitute one for the other alongside grilled foods or with bread, but expect a different flavour. Basic mast-o khiar with mint tastes milder than a garlic-heavy tzatziki. You'll notice a bigger difference if you substitute a version containing raisins and rose petals, especially in a savoury wrap.
To make mast-o khiar more like tzatziki, use thicker yoghurt, drain the cucumber and add garlic, olive oil and a little lemon juice or vinegar. To make a tzatziki-style mixture closer to basic mast-o khiar, omit the added acid and oil, reduce or leave out the garlic, and use dried mint. You'll get the closest match by starting with unseasoned yoghurt rather than adjusting a finished dip.
How should you store mast-o khiar and tzatziki?
Keep both dishes covered in the fridge and use clean utensils when serving. Cucumber may release water as the mixture sits; stir it back in or carefully pour off excess liquid. For the best texture, make a small batch and add walnuts shortly before serving if you want them to stay crisp.
Keep yoghurt dishes refrigerated at 4°C (40°F) or below. Follow the U.S. Food and Drug Administration guidance to refrigerate perishable foods within two hours, or within one hour when the temperature exceeds 32°C (90°F). Put out a small serving bowl and replenish it from the fridge rather than leaving the whole batch on the table.
Sources
- Are You Storing Food Safely? · FDA (fda.gov)